Happy May the Fourth. This is the last in a series of
Star Wars adoption movie reviews. In this sixth film, a
rebellion is raging against an evil Emperor, and Luke confronts his father in
an attempt to save his from his master, the Emperor.
Here are links in case you want to read the Adoption Movie Guides of the earlier films: The Phantom Menace, Attack of the Clones, Revengeof the Sith, A New Hope, and The Empire Strikes Back.
How is This Relevant
to Adoption?
Luke
and Leia were both adopted. As is the case in some adoptions, they didn’t know
about each other. In this film, though, Luke and Leia learn that they are
siblings and (spoiler alert……….) it’s confirmed that Darth Vader is their
father. Luke confronts his father because he believes that his father must have
some good in him yet. His father believes that it is too late to change, and
that his allegiance is inextricably devoted to the Emperor. There is a
recurring theme of secrecy – Luke is confronts a mentor who had lied to him
about his father. There is also a theme of the importance of genetics – Luke and
Leia have both inherited skills and gifts from their father.
Strong Points
The
film acknowledges the connection between Luke and his father – they can sense
each other. Luke holds out faith that his father is still good, deep down, in
spite of his actions and in spite of others’ advice to the contrary. In the
end, Luke’s faith is justified. Luke and his father are reconciled by the end
of the movie. Each saves the other. In a touching scene, Vader asks to see
Luke, face to face. He expresses that
Luke has saved him, by helping him turn from evil to good. In his dying words,
he tells Luke, “You were right about me. Tell your sister, you were right.”
Luke
directly tells Leia, “it won’t be easy for you to hear, but you must. The Force
is strong in my family. My father has it. I have it. And my sister has it. Yes,
it’s you, Leia.” Leia responds, “I know, somehow, I’ve always known.”
Challenges
When
Luke shares the news with Leia that they are siblings, he asks, “Do you
remember your mother – your real
mother?” “Birth” or “first” mother might have worked better here. Leia only
remembers that her mother was “kind, but sad.”
Prior
to their reconciliation, Vader acknowledges that he may have to kill Luke. Luke
cuts off Vader’s hand in a (bloodless) duel.
Weak Points
I’m
troubled by the advice that the good guys give Luke. Yoda and Obi-Wan (Ben)
Kenobi are two Jedi masters, supposedly wise warrior/philosophers. They chose
to hide the truth from Luke – and when they are confronted, their answers and
advice are troubling and disappointing.
Luke
asks Yoda if Darth Vader is his father. Yoda rolls over and says he needs rest.
Luke persists, and Yoda acknowledges, “your father he is. Told you, did he?”
Luke explains that he has. Yoda replies that it is “unexpected… and
unfortunate.” Luke asks, “Unfortunate that I know the truth?” Yoda replies, “No.
Unfortunate that you rushed” and that you were “not ready.” And then, Luke
apologizes. In essence, Yoda believed that Luke couldn’t yet handle the truth
about his father, and so, Luke ends up apologizing for doing wrong, which seems
like a type of false guilt that might be unfortunately familiar to adoptees.
Yoda
advises Luke that if he ever gives into anger, fear, or aggression, they will
forever “dominate your destiny.” This seems to imply that people can’t change.
Later,
Luke confronts Ben. Luke asks, “Why didn’t you tell me? You told me Vader
betrayed and murdered my father.” Ben’s response leaves much to be desidred, “Your
father was seduced and became Vader. When that happened, the good man who was
your father was destroyed. So what I told you was true, from a certain point of
view.” Luke questions this, and then affirms that there is still good in his
father. Ben replies that Vader is twisted and evil. Luke protests, “I can’t
kill my own father.” And Ben responds with the chilling line, “Then the Emperor
has already won.”
Ben
does affirm that Leia is Luke’s sister, but he cautions that Luke’s insight and
feelings could serve evil. He encourages him to “bury your feelings deep down.”
Some scenes might be frightening to young
viewers – there are threats of peril and laser-based sci-fi violence.
Recommendations
Return
of the Jedi is a satisfying conclusion to the six-film series. If you watch
only the middle films, Anakin seems inescapably evil, but the series taken in
as a whole shows that he is a person with loves and passions who made a series
of understandable but damaging and wrong choices. He could not care for his
children, but remained, at his essence, a good person – or at the very least, a
person who was not wholly evil. Luke’s faith in his father’s innate goodness is
affirmed. This could be a powerful film for adopted viewers and their families.
The deeper message about Vader’s goodness might be most helpful to viewers who
have reached the mid-teenage years. The movie can be used to illustrate that –
just because your birthparent has done wrong things – they aren’t a bad person,
and neither are you.
Questions for Discussion after the movie
Was
Luke right? Did Vader still have good in him?
How
do you separate what a person has done from whether they are good? The Emperor
and Vader both did horrible things – what made them different?
How
did Leia feel when she learned that Luke was her brother?
How
do you think Luke felt when he asked Ben why he had been lied to?
Have you ever been lied to about your adoption?
Is there anyone that you think still has good in them, even if other people seem to think otherwise?
I have enjoyed this series, Addison.
ReplyDeleteMay the 4th!
Thanks, Lori! I hope you eventually see & enjoy the films :)
Delete