Tuesday, May 9, 2017
The Hanji Box Adoption Movie Review
Hannah is recently divorced and is in the process of
downsizing her home. Rose, the young adult daughter that Hannah adopted from
Korea, is helping Hannah pack, and seems distressed by the situation. When
Hannah accidentally damages a special box, Rose is distraught, believing that
she brought the box with her from Korea. Hannah sets off to a Korean district
of her city to try to repair the box. Her journey brings her into contact with
a visiting Korean artist. Together, they talk about the complexities of
adopting from Korea, and the artist shares a perspective that Hannah had not
previously considered. Their meeting is short, but influential, and he invites
her to come visit him in Korea one day.
The Adoption
Connection
Rose appears to have some unsettled emotions connected to
her adoption. She confronts Hannah about the broken box, saying “my real mother
gave this to me,” and also accusing her of “always wreck[ing] things that are
important to me." The complexity of emotions is realistic, as Rose’s
distress regarding her parents’ divorce and her father’s impending remarriage interact
with her experience of being an adult adoptee.
The artist and Hannah have a very interesting and thoughtful
conversation about cultural identity in international adoption. The artist also
explains one Korean perspective of the international adoption of Korean babies.
He asks some interesting questions.
Strong Points
The artist raises some very poignant thoughts and questions
regarding international adoption and identity. When Hannah suggests that her
daughter is American, the artist replies, “You raised her like an American
because you are American,” and then asks whether Rose really was turned from
Korean into an American. He also asks whether Hannah adopted Rose “for her, or
for you?” Hannah honestly acknowledges that she isn’t sure. The artist’s
questions are deep, but kind and not judgmental. This is a very
thought-provoking film.
Recommendations
Adults touched by international
adoption may find The Hanji Box to be very thought provoking. It should be part
of the preparation process for adults considering international adoption,
particularly from Korea. This is a very thoughtful, 59-minute film.
Questions for
Discussion
What motivated Hannah to adopt? Was it one main thing
(infertility or a desire to give love to a baby
that seems to be without a
nurturing family), or a combination of both?
Is Rose Korean or American, or some combination of the two?
What would Hannah gain from going to Korea? What might Rose
gain?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment